Not Without Hope Parents Guide

Not Without Hope Rated R by Motion Picture Rating (MPA) for language throughout.

Joe Carnahan feels almost destined to take the helm of a film like “Not Without Hope.” His career has always gravitated toward bruising, tightly wound action dramas from the cold, blue-steel aesthetic of “Narc” to the anarchic mayhem of “Smokin’ Aces,” and of course the primal, teeth-chattering intensity of “The Grey,” where Liam Neeson squared off against nature in all its murderous indifference. You can sense that lineage immediately in this new survival thriller; Carnahan knows exactly how to orchestrate chaos without losing sight of the humans trapped inside it.

Adapted from the nonfiction account of the same name, “Not Without Hope” drops the audience directly into the churning Gulf of Mexico, recreating the 2009 boating disaster that left four friends two of them NFL players stranded after their small vessel overturned. The broad framework is familiar territory; if you’ve seen “The Perfect Storm,” “White Squall,” or “Adrift,” you’ll recognize the narrative beats. And yes, Carnahan and co-writer E. Nicholas Mariani occasionally rely on dialogue that echoes decades of sea-survival dramas. Still, what emerges is surprisingly gripping: a sharply modulated piece of survival cinema that draws strength from its cast, its pockets of quiet self-reflection, and Juanmi Azpiroz’s documentary-style camerawork, which plants us at water level, bobbing and freezing right alongside the characters.

Zachary Levi usually deployed for charm and buoyant energy in “Chuck” and the “Shazam!” series shifts gears to play Nick Schuyler, a personal trainer helping buddies Marquis Cooper (Quentin Plair) and Corey Smith (Terrence Terrell) prep for the grind of another NFL season. When their friend Will Bleakley (Marshall Cook) arrives at a barbecue freshly unemployed, the other three fold him into their plans for a casual morning fishing trip out of Clearwater, Florida. The casting skews a decade or two older than their real-life counterparts, but the physical credibility remains. These men feel like they’ve lived in their bodies strong, capable, and quietly competitive.

Carnahan doesn’t linger long on backstories, but he sketches an easy camaraderie among the four — the shorthand of people who’ve sweated and laughed together for years. And refreshingly, the film doesn’t sanitize their language. These are athletes, friends, men who rib each other with relentless profanity. When Will proudly lists off his sandwich inventory “twenty fcking PB&Js and twenty fcking turkey and cheese” the line doesn’t feel like a gag so much as the sound of real people talking. Carnahan commits fully to the rough edges, earning the film’s R rating not through gore but through honesty and the rawness of what these men endure.

Disaster strikes when their anchor snags roughly 70 miles offshore. The attempt to torque the boat forward and free it instead flips the vessel, tossing all four into the water. Their phones are sealed away in the cabin, unreachable. A storm bears down. From here, the film adopts a ticking-clock structure title cards marking “13 Hours Lost at Sea,” then “20 Hours,” then “42” as we alternate between the desperate efforts of the men to right the boat, conserve heat, and signal passing ships, and the anxious, helpless waiting on land. Floriana Lima (as Nick’s fiancée, Paula) and Jessica Blackmore (as Marquis’s wife, Rebekah) inhabit the traditional “worried loved ones at home” roles with dignity, even if the script confines them mostly to strained phone calls and long, fearful silences.

Highly Recommended: Man Finds Tape Parents Guide

JoBeth Williams, luminous as ever four decades after “The Big Chill” and “Poltergeist,” brings an aching emotional center to the film as Nick’s mother, Marcia a woman refusing to surrender to despair even as the Coast Guard’s hope dwindles. And Josh Duhamel, playing real-life Captain Timothy Close, grounds the rescue operation with a quiet professionalism that feels lived-in. One monologue in particular his chilling explanation of hypothermia’s final stages, how it fractures the mind before it claims the body lands with a weight that lingers. When Carnahan cuts back to the men in the water, we understand exactly what’s happening beneath their shivers and stares. It’s brutal. It’s tender. It’s almost unbearable.

Because the real tragedy was so widely reported fifteen years ago, the outcome is not a mystery: only one man survived. Carnahan approaches each death with clear eyes and respect, letting the roar of the sea fade into a mournful score, allowing us to sit with the enormity of the loss rather than manipulating it. Malta stands in convincingly for the Gulf, and the cast spends so much time submerged or soaked that you can practically feel the cold leeching into your own bones. The film honors the truth of what happened without tipping into exploitation a balance that’s much harder to achieve than it looks.

Content Breakdown for Parents

Violence & Intensity: No gore, but sustained peril as characters endure cold water, exhaustion, injuries, and the psychological toll of survival.

Several scenes depict men slipping into hypothermia shaking, hallucinating, or falling unconscious.

A few moments feel emotionally raw, especially for sensitive viewers.

The overall atmosphere is tense and claustrophobic, not unlike The Perfect Storm but on a smaller, more personal scale.

Language: A steady stream of strong profanity throughout very much in the way a group of adult friends might talk around each other. Frequent F-words, plus other adult language.No slurs or hate speech, just the rough locker-room banter of athletes and longtime friends.

Parents sensitive to language should expect a high volume of it.

Sexual Content / Nudity: None.

Drugs, Alcohol & Smoking: No drug use. Very minor alcohol consumption appears early on during a pre-trip gathering, but it’s not a plot point.

Parental Concerns

Parents should be aware that:

The film’s emotional heaviness may linger.

The ending is not upbeat (if you know the true story, you’ll understand why), though the movie handles this with grace and respect.

Some teens may have difficulty watching prolonged suffering or scenes of hypothermia.

The language is constant and unfiltered.

This is not a popcorn thriller it’s more somber, slow-burn, and grounded.